Crisis of Marriage in America

By Yaser Birjas | 2026-01-13T12:56:57.860364+00:00 | Topic: Marriage

Crisis of Marriage in America - Yaser Birjas

Crisis of Marriage in America - Yaser Birjas

Opening

أَسْلَامُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ

"Peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you."

بِسْمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمَٰنِ الرَّحِيمِ

"In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful."

الْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ رَبِّ الْعَالَمِينَ، وَصَلَّى اللهُ وَسَلَّمَ وَبَارَكَ عَلَى نَبِيِّنَا مُحَمَّدٍ وَعَلَى آلِهِ وَصَحْبِهِ وَسَلَّمَ تَسْلِيمًا كَثِيْرًا، ثُمَّ أَمَّا بَعْدُ

"All praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds. May Allah’s peace, blessings, and grace be upon our Prophet Muhammad, his family, and his companions. To proceed:"

It seems that people don't get really bored whenever we talk about a subject like love and marriage. So you guys are already smiling and laughing, which means it is true.

It's very hard and difficult to find people away from subjects like marriage and love, specifically in a community full with youth, mashallah, and also youthful hearts, is always into the idea of love and marriage in order to rejuvenate their lives and see a future for themselves as well. Subhanallah, the issue of marriage, the issue of love, even though Allah said clearly in the Quran that it's one of his bounties and favors upon mankind.

Quranic Verse

وَمِنْ آيَاتِهِ أَنْ خَلَقَ لَكُم مِّنْ أَنفُسِكُمْ أَزْوَاجًا لِتَسْكُنُوا إِلَيْهَا وَجَعَلَ بَيْنَكُم مَّوَدَّةً وَرَحْمَةً إِنَّ فِي ذَلِكَ لَآيَاتٍ لِّقَوْمٍ يَتَفَكَّرُونَ

"And of His signs is that He created for you from yourselves mates that you may find tranquility in them; and He placed between you affection and mercy. Indeed in that are signs for a people who give thought."

It is among his sign is this, that he created for you, made for amongst yourselves, in order for you to dwell in tranquility with them, peace and tranquility, and he has placed between your hearts love and mercy.

(إِنَّ فِي ذَلِكَ لَآيَاتٍ لِّقَوْمٍ يَتَفَكَّرُونَ) Indeed, they are in our signs for those who reflect. So Allah made the issue of marriage one of his signs. One of these magnificent and brilliant signs in this creation.

Main Body

How men get attracted to women, women get attracted to men. How men fall in love with women, women with men. How they come together in order to look and find this peace and tranquility.

All by the will of Allah. Even Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم) acknowledging this as a fact of creation. He encouraged people to go and pursue this peace and tranquility as quick as possible.

He never encouraged people to delay marriages. He always encouraged that. He encouraged people, young men and women, to pursue marriage as quick as possible.

Hadith

يَا مَعْشَرَ الشَّبَابِ، مَنِ اسْتَطَاعَ مِنكُمُ الْبَاءَةَ فَلْيَتَزَوَّجُ

(Sahih al-Bukhari 5066)

"Saying,"

And this is an instruction specifically given to men because usually they are the ones who should be initiating their proposals. Saying, ya ma'shar al-shabab, you, al-shabab, the youth, manastata'a aminkumul ba'a Anyone who finds himself capable, means financially, physically, all aspects. If you find yourself capable of getting married, falya tazawwaj.

You should go and pursue it. You should go and get married. The Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) given now the reason for this.

That it will be better for you, will help you lower your gaze and protect yourself, your chastity from the haram. But if you couldn't (فَعَلَيْهِ بِالصَّوْم) Anyone who was unable then should go and adhere to fasting. Fast as much as you can in order to suppress this overwhelming desire until Allah makes it easy for you.

With all these instructions from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) And this beautiful sign from Allah in this creation. It seems that living here in the West, things are getting difficult and more difficult. Look around you.

And ask yourself the question, are you married? And just let me see the show of hands. How many of you guys are single? Raise your hand if you're single. Brothers and sisters.

Maybe because you're young. But how old are you? You're still young though. So in traditional societies, people of your age should all be, mashallah, they would have two or three children.

They would be well-rounded in life, well-established. Men and women. So they know they continue the process of creation of mankind, and they continue the process of establishing societies.

And they're going to be going on further and further until Allah wills. But still though, with all these things we know and realize how difficult it is for people to get married. At least here in America.

Even if you go and you get married, there are so many problems, so many obstacles you have to go over, and you have to try to overcome before even you reach that level. And even if Allah blessed you to be among those who are few in number here in America, who gets married will be very difficult and hard to maintain that relationship without any problems. Dealing with the youth, and also those who are married, alhamdulillah rabbil alamin, dealing with this class, fiqh of love and love notes, sometimes it brings a lot of wonders how people experience beautiful and loving relationships with each other.

But at the same time, you will see some relations are going up and down based on their circumstances. Makes you feel so, subhanallah, annoyed by the reality of marriage for all Muslim youth here in America. People, they ask the question, well hold on a second, is it even possible to raise a Muslim family in an environment like here in the West? I mean, you're talking about traditional societies, alhamdulillah, where Muslims are overwhelming, you know, majority.

So therefore, everything, all the circumstances will help to establish an Islamic society, a Muslim family, alhamdulillah rabbil alamin, help in the process of upbringing our children. What about here? Is it hard and difficult really to bring up a Muslim family? The answer is yes. But is it impossible? The answer is no.

So then, why do we have all these issues and all these problems? Can you really live in the West and maintain a Muslim identity and establish a good Muslim family? We have some problems. And this is a crisis in marriage for the Muslim ummah, Muslim community living in America and the West in general. And honestly, exploring many, many of the activity sessions I had conducted with my students in the Fiqh of Love and also Love Note classes and seminars, you come with so many problems and crises that they produce for you.

Dealing with all these issues, it's very hard and difficult to finish in a few minutes. But I have summarized some of them, at least just to shed some light on some of these probably most important problems I have seen among the youth here in America. And I have also divided this into three different groups.

Three Categories of Problems

First Category: Conventional Views

The first set of problems falls under conventional views. We have specific conventional views that put some obstacles in the way to get married. The second, some gender issues, is something contemporary to Muslim society.

And it's now the influence of the Western society. So, what are they exactly? And then we will see, inshallah, some cultural issues as well. As for these conventional views, number one, the ideals of love and marriage.

If you ask the young men and young women here in this society, even in this room, what are your views regarding love and marriage? They will have some kind of beautiful ideals. And I call them ideals because all what they have in their mind is just that beautiful image and heavenly bliss. But in reality, sometimes it's almost impossible to reach that level.

You have to deal with the circumstances. You have to accept that you need to compromise. So you see, young men, they would like to have the most beautiful woman, the most talented woman, the smartest lady, she's excellent in cooking, she's, mashallah, basically all these beautiful qualities in one woman.

Same thing, the ladies would like to wait for this, mashallah, athletic guy, very smart, intelligent, rich and wealthy, kind and caring, all these beautiful images. I would say the only place you can find a man or a woman like this is in Al-Jannah. In dunya, it's very hard.

You ask those who, once they initiate their idea about getting married, they want to experience love first because they believe, given what they have learned in this society, you cannot marry someone unless you love them. That is true. What do you mean by love? Is it that this kind of fairytale mentality, that you see her, she's beautiful, she must be perfect, so I love her? And he's handsome, and he's a prince, so he's rich, so I love him? Is that all? Can we just rationalize the concept of love? What does it exactly mean? What's going to happen next? We see in this society with all these ideas about love that you have to practice and experience that relationship before even you get married.

You have to experience that love before you get married. Still though, we have so many people, they go for divorce after they get married in this society. Why? Because they realize love is not just a lip service.

It is something beyond what you claim. It is something practical that you need to prove. If you love me, then show it to me.

And you need to see this person who is really practical, who understands the meaning of love, and they are ready to sacrifice their life for this relationship. What do we call it? Marriage. It's a matter of commitment.

If you love somebody, you need to commit for them. It's not about, let me try it. There are no trials in marriage.

Marriage doesn't come with a receipt. You have 30 days trial. Just bring the receipt, and we're ready just to revoke the marriage.

It doesn't work like that, believe me. You have to commit. And when you commit, you commit for a relationship and never put failure as an option.

In the mind of many, many people, young men and women, when they go into a relationship, you can see that, because I conduct sometimes even marriage contracts, I can see these views from the way they try to stipulate and put conditions in their marriage contract. So they say, you know what? We need $500 only as a mahr, which is muqaddam, which means upfront. And then $50,000 deferred mahr.

You ask the people, what do you mean by $50,000? What is that for? Well, just in case, if things don't work, really we want to make sure that she will stand on something solid. Okay, what if he gets so abusive that he says, you know, I don't have $50,000, therefore I'm going to go after you until you ask for khulr. So the relationship becomes so sour, they start abusing each other, fighting, and even after they get married Islamically, they go to the court to finish it legally, because they know if they're going to go to the Islamic divorce, it's going to look different.

So they have to go by law, and that's for them to ensure extra amount of what they have earned in their marital life. So we do have some problems. Views of love are mixing honestly, are contaminating the idea of marriage, and the idea of the earnestness of marriage and love, which is family life.

Family life is very, very important. Part of these conventional views, as we mentioned earlier, the premarital relations, because of now I need to fall in love with this man or this woman before marriage, so therefore I have to experience him and her. Eventually, talking about some conservative communities, Muslim communities, they need to know each other, and they start knowing each other, and then it gets a little bit more relaxed, so they start going with one another, talking over the phone for hours and hours, and then they go without any chaperones or mahram and so on, and sometimes they fall into the haram before they get married.

And I have, unfortunately, had to go and get involved in some of these issues in Muslim communities, because people, they get extra excited. And they know that they have promised that we're going to get married anyway, eventually, so why not? I need to know him, and I need to know her. But to what extent? What exactly do you need to know about him and about her? How loving this person is going to be? How caring this person is going to be? What exactly do you need to know? Yes, Islam gives you the chance to get together, to the supervision of the family, and the mahram, to know one another.

But it has to be supervised. Why? To rationalize the concept of love. It's not just about him, you know, flowing all these emotions to you, so you can just succeed by these words.

There's somebody else saying, hold on a second, you just spoke all these emotions right now, I need you to show this in practice. What do you mean by this? What are you offering him? What is going on here? What do you do? How are you going to go about all these issues in life? So trying always to build these issues for the family life, for the future of the family. Number three of the controversial views.

The issue of finances. Ask most of those young people, say, what's the problem with you guys? Why aren't you getting married right now? Well, I'm not ready yet. What do you mean by ready? Financially, I'm not yet stable.

Okay, how old are you? 35 years old. Subhanallah, 35 years old, still not married, because your financial is not stable? What have you been doing all these years? Where did you send your money? I mean, if it was for charity, Alhamdulillah Rabbil Alameen, Allah reward you. It means you're investing with Allah.

But if it was just on PlayStation games, that would be a big problem. So indeed, if this is the case, then you will never be ready for marriage. At all.

But yes, finances. What do we mean by that? For many people, the issue of finances is a big, big challenge. And we have some culture and also some of these that contributes to these controversial views of marriage.

And conventional views of marriage is that you have to finish your education completely, which goes with it. So finances most likely would go with education. And when you say education, for many, many people, it means PhD.

Or at least, MD. To ensure future. If you're not a doctor, I don't know how successful you're going to be in life.

That's what we have in our minds. If you basically go for an imam position, may Allah be with you. Are you going to survive? And we don't know that even the market for imams has changed.

There are some Muslim communities looking for imams, community leaders, of strong leadership. They start with $85,000. Just please, come and lead our community.

And I heard other communities even asking for more, offering more, just we need someone to lead. So the issue of finances is not about our own perception. You have to be an engineer, you have to be a doctor, you have to be this, you have to be that.

You need to be successful in life. That's all. How? What if you're a teacher? Can't you manage your money very well, inshallah, and not survive in this life? Yes.

Besides, when you say stable, financial stable, what does that mean? You need to first have a house, to have a car, and then to have the whole furniture already in the house and so on before you even get married. I mean, that's true. You need to have some place where you can start with your life.

But it doesn't have to be a huge mortgage that you put on your back and your shoulder in order to survive. Because of this view right now, many young men and women, they look for the other party, of course, to be probably as equally rich, if not even more. So they want a working partner.

Young men, they're looking for a sister who has a degree so they could go and work, inshallah, to ensure a better financial situation. Well, if you would like to take that route, that is fine. But you're going to have to be the consequence of this decision.

How come? The more you earn, that's now statistically speaking, the more you earn, the more you spend. And you will never reach that satisfaction. Never.

So if you both earn $120,000, why should you go for a house that costs maybe $50,000? No, we're going to buy a bigger house. And, mashallah, a new house. And you drive the same car? No way.

It has to be a new car. So they go and they buy two cars. And both are new.

If not even leased. Furniture. Oh, no way.

You are not going to bring anything from your apartment. Everything has to be new. So they buy new furniture.

And sometimes they leave the tags on the furniture forever. Just to feel that it's new. So we always have all these high expectations to our finances.

Before we even get married. We start our marriage with a huge financial burden. Ask most of those young men who start with this actually huge financial burden.

Besides their loan, of course. The college and student loan. And it's not a point right now to say it's haram or halal.

But the point is that they start with a lot of burden on them. Financial burdens. And then when they start their marital life, they always throw the blame on their families.

On their wives. Why? It's because of you I'm carrying all this burden. And that's when they always start getting in trouble and start fighting each other.

And the relationship gets sour and even sometimes bitter to the divorce. The issue of education. In one of the activities we had in this class, the seminars about marriage and love.

We asked the young men and women a question. We said, why do you delay your marriages? And they gave different views, of course. One of these issues was delaying the marriage actually.

The question itself, delaying marriage, was objected by some sisters. Saying, no, it's not about delaying, we are waiting. And let me just read to you what were the reasons these young men and women delaying their marriages.

And I'm now reading real actual statistics. Number one reason. Number one reason for men and for women to delay and defer their marriages further and further.

Which means if it was left for them, I would like to marry yesterday, not even tomorrow. But now there are some obstacles. Number one reason for these young men and women delaying their marriages, guess what? Parents.

Number one reason, parents. And we shall talk about this inshallah when we talk about cultural gaps. But parents will be number one reason for them to delay their marriages.

Number two, for men, finances. For women, education. It's almost the same.

Somehow. Number three, for men, education. Which means if I can't find myself financially stable and continue with my education, I don't mind.

I'll get married. I just need to be financially stable more. For women, number three, fear and intimidation.

Of what? They give different reasons. Fear of oppression, fear of control, fear of past experiences, fear of family responsibilities, and so forth, all these kind of things. For men, number four, it was fear.

And that's fear of what? Fear of commitment and fear of rejection. Men, they get intimidated when they go and propose. And many people, they come to me, young people, because we don't have the same

traditional ways of getting along our marriages.

So like, the mother usually takes the role in seeking the best maybe match for her son and so on. They don't do that anymore over here, except for a few.

So he's trying to look for himself.

And now he sees that she might be a potential maybe wife. This might be a prospective bride and so on, but how do I go about it? And I'm afraid. They get so scared of asking.

So they fear rejection. Then number five, or for ladies, I mean, number four, which is very amusing here, it's lack of proposals. So the guys fear of rejection, they don't propose.

And the ladies, they're waiting because of lack of proposals. How are you going to bridge the gap right now? What should we do? We told the guys, don't worry, just go and ask. And the ladies, they have some list of conditions that made those guys scared away.

Number five, lack of halal venues, which is true. So we don't know how to go, where to go. Imams, not too many imams are helpful, because they don't want to be responsible for a relationship that might turn so sour.

Families, they would like to give, to force specific relations on us, so therefore we don't want their interference in our relationship. Parents, they always put these conditions in our way. And even if we say, fine, I want to get married, the parents will say, no, until you finish your education.

What do I mean by education? It's not even bachelor's degree anymore, by the way. Bachelor's degree is just like finishing kindergarten today. So you have to have a master's degree or a PhD.

So you need to go, keep going on in your education. Number six, culture. Culture becomes a huge problem.

We shall again, as I said, we talk about it, inshallah, later in this session. But from this, as you see, young men and women, they have their own perspective on why they're delaying their marriages. But still though, the sisters, which I wanted to bring here regarding the issue of education, as one of these conventional views, the issue of education for sisters, they say, listen, it's not a matter that we're delaying our marriage, because it's not in our hand.

Usually the guy should initiate the proposal, which is true. Most ladies, they're expecting and still waiting for this prince charm to come on his white horse and say, let's go. And they're waiting.

So they call, they say, we are not delaying actually, but we are waiting. Which means if they don't propose, we're going to keep waiting for too long. As a solution for this, basically, because they have already been, alhamdulillah, in the process of education and learning and certification, they say, listen, as

long as I'm going to be waiting for a suitable proposal to come, why not then just continue my education? So they go and they join graduate school.

What they don't realize, the more they go in this field of graduate school and then PhDs and then career-oriented views and vision and so on, the more these guys get scared. They say, she's going to be overqualified for me. So therefore, the best way to do it is to go traditionally.

And I guess you all know and you hear about so many of these young boys, they go and they marry from overseas. Why? I don't want to get involved with this problem. You see, I just don't want to get all these headaches.

So it's better just to get someone who's traditional. She just wants to be my wife. I don't want really a co-worker in the house.

I don't want to have these problems from her work with me and so on. So they have all these issues. Education is not haram.

Receiving the highest degree of education is not haram itself. But now we're dealing with reality. And I want you just to open your eyes to the reality.

I'm not here promoting any specific let's say marriage or even pattern. I'm just opening your eyes to what's going on in reality. Most of those guys fear rejection, so they get intimidated.

Most of those sisters, they're waiting. And sometimes they're waiting on the wrong station. So therefore, something has to be done.

And we need to realize and understand the concept of marriage and love. Which brings us to the issue of gender. Gender issues.

Second Category: Gender Issues

Now gender issues, if you read any Islamic literature, specifically traditional Islamic literature, books of fiqh, books of aqidah and akhlaq and so on, the concept of gender and gender expectations, gender issues, they don't exist in these traditional classical works of Faryal. But they do exist in the contemporary works of Muslim scholars, or at least students of knowledge. Because it's a true challenge.

And being a true challenge, it has to be tackled from an Islamic perspective. To see what exactly is going on in our Muslim society. So when you deal with the gender issues, the issue of men and women, the role of men in the society, the role of women in the society, who takes precedence over the other, is it a matter of, you know, patriarchy? It means the man takes control of everything in the society and women, they just have some kind of complementary role in the society.

What exactly should be the role of men and women in society? Based on how you answer this question, then you're going to have to touch on the issue of family life. Because if you're going to say men and women should share the workforce, and do and help around the society and so on, which is good, Alhamdulillah Rabbil Alameen, on the account of whom? Family time. Family life.

Kids. Who's going to be raising your kids? Whether your parents, your in-laws, friends, nannies, or someone you don't know who? And that's, on the long run, going to create some kind of social instability in the society. In Islam, do we have anything such as Islamic feminism? What do you guys think? Do you have anything like Islamic feminism? The guys are scared to answer.

Even though, as I said, we might not have these issues tackled seriously in Islamic classical works of Fiqh and Sharia, but it is a real problem in the Muslim society. People, they grow up in traditional families with what we call a gender expectation. So what is the gender expectation for women? Gender expectation of women is that when they grow, they need to grow, of course, to prepare themselves for the family life.

To be wives. Or housewives. Today they call them homemakers.

Because housewives have some kind of negative connotation with it. So they just prefer to say homemaker. It's better.

So that's now traditional, of course, view. And this is now gender expectation from them. And most men, even the highly probably educated men in this society, from amongst the Muslims, they always go and go back to that view when it comes to marriage.

Yes, even if he wants his wife to work with him to help with the finances, they still go back traditional when it comes to gender expectations. So they want her to work, but at the same time she needs to be the housewife. So some of my business is with the house.

It's yours. You cook, you take care of the laundry, you take care of the kids, you do all these things. And for women, they're going to say, well, that's not fair.

Hold on a second. I mean, you agree that we should be partners, equal partners, because we believe in equality. So, why now you force me to do these things? So they get married, and the first few weeks and months, because now, again, they're in this in-love, heavenly bliss, but when they start feeling the reality of marriage, and how these expectations would be contradictory to their own personal views of marriage, that's when they start coming into fights, into arguments, and probably even ending their relationship with divorce.

Men, they expect themselves to be the breadwinners. So my job is just to go out and work. Once I'm done, that's it.

I want to go home just to chill out. And even if I stay at home for some time, I need to go out with my guys, with my friends. You know, just like in the old days, the hunting packs, how men, they used to go out just for hunting and sit together for days and nights and outside hours, and they come back with their games, and with the meat, with the bread, with the food, and they're so happy.

They expect their wives just to say, Jazakallah Khair, Mashallah, Barakallah Khair. Means no complaint. They don't want any complaints from their wives.

But again, influences from this culture, from the Muslim culture, has changed these conventional views of marriages. Means men and women now are facing the age of even Islamic feminism. Even women sometimes, unintentionally, they might fall into the pitfalls of this actually, of these views, and men don't know how to deal with it because for them it's even out of the question.

We are still Muslims, and therefore we have this patriarchal system. Means Allah says in the Quran,

الرِّجَالُ قَوَّامُونَ عَلَى النِّسَاءِ

which means men are qawwamun. Qawwamun means protectors, they're guardians, they are responsible for their families because of the preferences between them, based on these differences, Allah made one over the other, and finances.

They're responsible financially for the household. And if they compromise any of these two things, they're going to lose the concept of qawwamah. And that's why we see in this society right now, when both parties are working actually, it creates a lot of tension between the husband and wife.

Because now, the concept of qawwamah is no longer as it should be. Does it mean it's haram for women to work? Not at all, it's based on the circumstances. But I always suggest for the young men and women, before they get married, if they're going to be both working, they have to understand the consequences and set the rules for the future before they continue this relationship.

It's not that, you know, okay, alhamdulillah, we can manage it, because they don't know what you're talking about. After a few months, that's when they start realizing, oh my God, I didn't get married just to keep having a roommate with me in the house, I need a wife, I need my husband with me in the house. So that's when they start realizing a few months later, okay, hold on a second, the husband says, okay, I don't want you to work anymore.

I want you to stay at home. He says, no, I didn't spend all 13 years in my life to get my degree just to stay at home. So they start fighting over these issues.

And the relationship does not stay too long. Because of this, which brings us to one of these gender issues, even the structure of marriage has changed.

So we have different marriage patterns right now among the Muslims.

We have the traditional marriage, which is based on the traditional gender expectations. The man is the head of the house, the woman, she's taking care of all the other things in the house. And then we have contemporary pattern called egalitarian pattern.

When man and woman, they both believe that we are partners and equal in all aspects. Finances, parenting, household issues, you know, all these kind of things. So the man tells his wife, it's your business, you're the man.

Yeah, but you're also working. Well, the Rasulullah says, it's my money. Woman, whatever she earns, that's hers.

And whatever man earns, he has to participate and share with his wife. So therefore, that's how Islam, alhamdulillah, distributes the finances. But if the man says, yeah, but this is not true.

I mean, if you're going to be working without participating, I don't want you to work there. And again, we go into the same issue. So egalitarian, and the same thing, the man, for example, at night, he comes back from work so tired, he wants to get some sleep.

Now they have a child who keeps crying and weeping and so on. Gender expectation is that that's her business, not mine. So if the baby starts crying, the only thing he does is just he pushes his wife.

And she's crying. Can you go and check on her? What if she says, okay, it's your turn? Who said that? Who said we take turns here? It's your business. It's your job.

But they don't realize that now, they're endangering their relationship. We have also an intermediate pattern between both traditional and egalitarian, which is called transitional. People who believe in traditional views, but at the same time, in the process of moving towards, okay, I need to help around the house.

A man says, yes, I know I should help because the lifestyle we live here in the West is totally different. It's not like in Muslim countries where you have a lot of relatives around you who can help with everything that you want and so on. So therefore I have to be around the house as much as possible.

Which means I need to help with parenting, I need to help with the chores of the house, I need to be for you. Even sometimes, like in this style, I need to cook one day per week, for example, or two days. So they try to help around the house.

Same thing, the wife would say, yeah, I know it's very difficult for you to take care of the bills and so I'll just take care of this for you. Just make sure that we have enough money in the bank, and I'll take care of the check and the balances. So Islam, and this is not really, it's not a thing that needs to be ashamed of, is indeed a religion that supports patriarchal system in the family life.

One thing I want to mention regarding the issue of the system of patriarchy in Islam, I don't want you, when I say, when I bring the word patriarchal system, I don't want you to imagine the western interpretation of patriarchy, because they have a totally different interpretation to it. If you check the concept of patriarchy in the European society, because most of these views come from European experiences, back in the 14th, 15th, 16th century, and it's all based on religion, specifically Catholicism, and how the Catholic Church, you know, women in the society, and also in America over here, during the time of the conquistadors when they started coming to North America and South America, how they dealt with the issue of women and gender and so on, it's somehow something that really mankind should feel ashamed of how men treat women. So now when we bring the issue of patriarchy, that men should be the head of the house, and they should take care of the financial issues, and the social structure should be for women, and so on, we think that it's a matter of the same pattern, of oppression, of suppression, of complete control.

We don't realize that it's a matter of coordination and cooperation. Not corporation, it's cooperation, helping one another. And that's how Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) explained that.

In his own actions, how he dealt with his wife, (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), who said, I mean, he's the number one patriarchy man in his household. However, if you check his lifestyle with his wife, you'd be amazed. How could Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), being so lenient, for example, with his wife in certain issues.

How he treated them. How kind he was to them, (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam). And that's when he said,

(صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam),

خَيْرُكُمْ خَيْرُكُمْ لِأَهْلِهِ، وَأَنَا خَيْرُكُمْ لِأَهْلِهِ

(Sunan at-Tirmidhi 3895)

The best amongst you. Those are the best of their families, and I am the one who's the best of his family. (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam).

Interesting thing, regarding, to close this point, actually, when I was taken a long time ago, some books about history of feminism here in the West, I was really surprised and shocked. A book that was written back in the early 1990s, if not even late 1980s. And the introduction of the book, the first, actually on the sleeve from the inside, the first page, they called it this hadith.

They called it this hadith. Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam)

خَيْرٌكُمْ خَيْرُكُمْ لِأَهْلِهِ، وَأَنَا خَيْرُكُمْ لِأَهْلِهِ

That the best amongst you, those are the best of their families, and I am the best of my family. And in the introduction, they said, of course, Muhammad, Prophet of Islam. And then afterwards, in the introduction, they said that it is based on this and the experience of women in Islam.

It's been believed that Islam or Muhammad was the first advocate for women liberation. Of course, they wanted to do that on their own way, on perspective, but we do believe that women, they had a lot of rights, more than so many women, actually, in Europe, until even this day.

Third Category: Cultural Issues

As for the cultural issues, some of these cultural issues that contribute to the crisis of women and marriage in the West, number one, prearranged marriages.

Parents, and we all know, Alhamdulillah, may Allah reward them for their efforts, for all their hardships that they had to endure in order to bring us up to become, mashallah, grown up. And even their support and help in order to finish our education and become adults and successful in our life, we know all of that. However, sometimes parents, they think that they take this for granted, that now, since I did all this for you, then it's my turn to put the seal on it, which is your marriage.

Once you're married, Alhamdulillah, I'm out of it. That's what they think. So they always think that, you know what, my role would finish when I just get you, inshallah, on the road.

And the last thing I need to do for you is just to help you get married. And when I want to help you get married, I want you to marry the best person to you. The most suitable match.

So they make as much as possible, all the efforts possible, for them, in order to bring you the person that you really need to get married to. It's more, it's between men and women. Some people, they think, this is now forced marriages or pre-arranged marriages.

It just happens, you know, it's an advantage for men, of course, a disadvantage for women. Actually, it's on both sides. Sometimes it's an advantage, sometimes it's a disadvantage.

Even sometimes guys, they fall victims for these pre-arranged marriages. Just like women, sometimes they fall victims of this. And sometimes, people, it's not a matter of being a victim, or victimized, actually, but it becomes really a privilege.

And alhamdulillah, an advantage for you to have a pre-arranged marriage, to help you go through life in an easy way, without going after so many proposals, chasing illusions, and so on. So it might, sometimes it has some kind of benefit, and sometimes it would have some disadvantages. Not all pre-arranged marriages are wrong, but not all of them are also right.

So, the parents, they would come and they try to force, of course, their patterns on their kids. Say, you know what? I want to marry this person. And they put some kind of parental pressure.

Like a dua. If you don't listen to me, if you don't accept this person, I'm going to make dua against you. I will never be satisfied with you.

Why? Why? But at the same time, kids, they need to realize that the parents are doing this out of love, not out of hate. Your parents, they love you so much. And even if you become 50 years old, maybe older, you're going to always be looked at as my little boy and my little girl.

Because you're still the children for them. So they're going to always try to take care of you. Even this happened with Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam).

Rasulullah was a messenger of Allah. When he used to come to Medina, Umm Ayman, his witness, he was a little baby when she nursed him. And now he's a grown up, he's a great messenger of Allah, (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), and she's an old lady.

She used to cook some food for him. So when he comes to visit, she goes, come and eat. And Rasulullah says, no, I don't want you.

So they start yelling at him, just like any mother. You're going to have to eat. Look at yourself.

You don't eat enough. So basically, always caring. And when they do that, it's not that she hated Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam).

No, she loved him so much, she said, listen, you keep going around, you have a strong mission that you need to care for and so on, so you need to eat enough. Come over here and eat. Even if he didn't like it, she wanted him just to go and eat.

And Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) was the most caring man ever walked on earth. Even when he sees Umm Ayman, his witness again, he would bring his coat for her to sit on it. The point is that our parents, when they do that, they have their own views, they have their own perspective.

They love us so much and that's why they want to help you. So let's solve all this problem quickly, so you can get along with your life inshallah. Again, they don't realize sometimes that they might hurt us unintentionally.

And therefore, please, don't get offended when your parents try to help you arrange your marriage, but try to come together and understand how to go about it and what exactly you should be looking for. For parents, I always suggest that you make this decision, final decision, for the kids. It's not your decision, it's theirs.

And Rasulullah (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) ensured that this decision should be made by those young people. When he said (صلى الله عليه وسلم - Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam), when he ensured that the proposal, or the final actual decision on any proposal, is the girls. No one has allowed to force his daughter into any marriage.

However, Allah gave men, which in this case, their parents, the father in particular, gave him the power of filtering these proposals, which we call al-wilaya. So you cannot force, but you can say no. And if the man takes it further to become more abusive, and says no, no, no, because he has something in his mind, they have the full right to go and object to his rejection, and his even power can be provoked from him, or revoked from him.

Document

One of these issues, cultural issues we have here, interracial marriages. Living in America, specifically in New York, you guys know better, it's a very, very multicultural society. You cannot say that there is one culture that is predominant here.

Everybody brings with them his own culture, and their own packages. Parents, sometimes, they keep living, and Sheikh Abdul-Bari mentioned here earlier, that most of the people here are coming from, at least, maybe not backgrounds, first, second, third generation. Most of these parents, they probably live here in New York, and being in a hub city like New York, and it's easy to travel overseas, so the Middle East and these countries become like the backyard for them.

They want to just have a cup of coffee, they just book a ticket, and then travel, and they come back again with a shopping cart with them. Very easy to do that. It's getting more expensive right now, so Allah Allah, maybe they're going to go back again, travel by boats, but still, for them, they live in a cultural society that's totally unique.

And those parents, with the technology that is now contributing to the problem through the satellite TV, people at home watching overseas TVs. So now they're becoming more entrenched into their own culture, and they expect their kids to do the same as well. What they don't realize is that their kids have already claimed their own culture.

And that culture, of course, is the American Muslim culture. The kids don't care about colors, they don't care about ethnicities, they don't care about background, they consider themselves Muslims, and that's it. So whether you're coming from Africa, from Europe, from an Arab, non-Arab society, and so on, for them, living together so long, they have broken all these cultural boundaries.

And now when they introduce someone from a different culture to their parents, oh my God, it's an alarming thing for them. Something must be going on in your mind. What's wrong with you? I mean, how come? He's not an Arab, she's not this, he's not that.

Why? Because again, we still live this kind of culture. For our kids, they don't care about these issues. I want both parties to be part of the solution.

Which means parents, you need to realize if you're living here in America, you should be living by body and by soul. It doesn't mean to adapt anything that is haram or wrong, but you should also consider the changes that are happening to your culture through your kids. And for the kids, I want you also to understand that your parents, they have legitimate concern when they come to consult their cultures and traditions.

It's very, very important. They would like to ensure for you, of course, a larger social network that you will need in your life. We don't perceive that because here we live under, of course, the influence of individualism.

So everybody wants to be himself or herself. But still, you cannot live without that cultural influence. So you need to open your mind, open your heart to all of these things.

Anyway, last thing I would like to conclude with, inshallah, so you can get to questions and answers if possible. The issue of parental expectations. You know, one of the reasons, or one of the things that we mentioned regarding the issue of why men and women delaying their marriages is the issue of education, issue of finances, and number one was parents.

Parents usually set the bar so high for their prospective, you know, spouse in the future. So they want the man to be a highly educated person, most intelligent man, rich and wealthy, very well established, very well rounded in life, and so on. They don't want someone who is still inexperienced in life.

But if you want someone like this, they're going to have to go through a lot of things before they get married. Those men, in order to meet the expectation of these parents, they go through a lot of modifications. So, bachelor's degree is not enough anymore to go and propose to a woman.

So you go with a bachelor's degree to a parent saying I have a bachelor's degree in, let's say, in IT, or even in education, or even in that. They say, well, how much do you earn anyway? That's, to me, the second question. Okay, I appreciate your degree, but how much do you earn from this? Well, when you say I have a master's degree in that, so they expect that you are earning more.

If you have a PhD degree, so you earn more. Okay, what happens when a man waits until he finishes his PhD degree? How old would he be? Not 40s, come on. I would assume that the person, when you finish your PhD, you'd be close to 30 years old.

Unless you were taking your time because of finances issues. So you might pass at 30 years old. Okay, when you pass 30 years old, and you want to get married, okay, what age would you be looking for for a spouse? So the humming already answering it.

Most men looking for a younger wife. And if you're looking for a younger wife, she's going to be probably in her master's degree or bachelor's degree. So he is going to have to wait a few more years before she finishes.

Besides, if you're going to be also looking for a younger girl, this younger girl, she's still in her wishful thoughts. She's thinking of that Prince Charming and looking at you in your 30s and 40s. So she goes and she waits even longer.

The more those young men and women wait for the perfect match, the longer they're going to stay in the market. And if they're going to stay longer and longer, people are going to get tired and sick and so on, and then eventually starts compromising a lot. When they reach a specific age, they say, okay, fine, forget about beauty, forget about wealth, forget about, I just need somebody.

And that would be it. And that would be wrong. We don't want you to reach to that level.

Again, I'm not promoting any specific here pattern for marriage, but I'm just trying to open our eyes to the reality of marriage. What exactly is going on? What is happening? What I really know personally from my experience in marriage counseling, even counseling pre-marital relations, also even conducting marriage contracts, all these kind of things will lie. Of the seminars, Love Notes and Fiqh of Love, I know more than what you think about this issue.

And by the way, I'm also married. And I have three kids. So I know what does that mean.

To be a father, to be a parent in the West. May Allah help you and assist you all to achieve that goal. So, therefore, as a conclusion, it's not one individual effort to solve the whole issue.

It's not one massive effort to solve the problem. It's a whole community effort. I know you guys have been visiting a lot of these matrimonial services, visiting a lot of these conferences, and visiting so many things to solve this issue, and it seems to be very difficult to find a solution easily for this because we're all waiting for a magic wand to say, Bismillah, and that's it.

The problem is solved. Everybody's married. Everybody has children already, and cars, and houses, and mashallah.

It doesn't work like this. We need very serious effort being done by all Muslim groups and communities and conferences and organizations in order to solve this issue. At least, let's start locally.

So here in New York, you have, mashallah, many, many masjids and many, many organizations. Why don't we start something in our masjid, then the next masjid, third masjid, fourth masjid, and start building these relations? How do we do that? First of all, I would suggest supervised sessions on a regular basis between the youth and their parents. Bridge the gap.

You don't have to discuss the issue of marriage only. You can discuss the issue of so many things. Education, finances, the future of the community, even council of leadership because you see in many, many organizations it's still in the hands of the first and the second generation.

They don't let go, you know, because they want to make sure that everything runs alhamdulillah as they have started it. And they don't really trust the new generation because they see that the new generation is not experienced in life yet. It's going to take them a while before they get to that point.

Why don't we start, which is number two, sessions, training sessions for the youth, young men and young women, and specifically on the concept of matrimonials and marriage. What's the meaning to be married? What does it take to get married? Even help them chart plans. Just if you chart the plan for them, to know from this day until let's say four years, three years, five years, I want to be married.

Help them inshallah by establishing these kind of training sessions. Encourage marriage. If your children come to you and say I want to get married, tell them okay, but first of all you need to quit playing PlayStation.

And then I can think about it seriously. So you need to show maturity. Young people, if you are serious about marriage, you need to show maturity.

Parents don't buy the issue of love. I'm telling you. That's how they think.

They want someone who thinks about responsibility. We know this is going to come after marriage. But you know, you have to think about what's coming next.

I'm not saying here that you completely quit the idea of love. You can develop that before marriage and even after marriage. Subhanallah.

How many relations do you know that they married before? We know each other actually before marriage. And they have been going on this much of successful relations for the past 10, 15, 20, 30, 40 years. Don't say because they were forced.

No, alhamdulillah, at least they're happy. Ask them, they're doing fine. So we do have it on both sides.

Hadith on Financial Sources

As the issue of finances, we teach in the Heavenly Hughes class a whole chapter on the issue of economy and finances from the Quran. People, they usually, when they think about finances and establishing themselves, you know, they always think of the conventional ideas of earning money. Which means higher education, more certification, training, conferences, all these kind of things and so on.

But there were so many things that we overlook. Mentioned in the Quran regarding sources to earn enough money. Some of these, just to mention some, inshallah, the issue of taqwa, fearing Allah.

وَمَن يَتَّقِ اللَّهَ يَجْعَل لَّهُ مَخْرَجًا وَيَرْزُقْهُ مِنْ حَيْثُ لَا يَحْتَسِبُ

Truly Allah fears who anyone, Allah will find him an exit from every difficulty and hardship, and provide for him from where he cannot even imagine. It's all coming by the will of Allah.

The second mentioned in the Quran, the issue of shukr, being thankful to Allah.

لَئِن شَكَرْتُمْ لَأَزِيدَنَّكُمْ

If you're grateful, I'll give you more. But if you're ungrateful, because you know most men and women when they ask them how much you earn, they say, not enough.

I'm still you know, behind. They're always behind. And you will die behind, believe me.

So therefore, just say, alhamdulillah. I'm happy. I'm happy with all I have.

Which creates the concept of contentment. Being content, you'll be rich. And you will feel that you're immediately ready for that, inshallah ta'ala.

And the last one, istighfar, seeking forgiveness from Allah.

وَقُلْتُ اسْتَغْفِرُوا رَبَّكُمْ إِنَّهُ كَانَ غَفَّارًا يُرْسِلِ السَّمَاءَ عَلَيْكُم مِّدْرَارًا وَيُمْدِدْكُم بِأَمْوَالٍ وَبَنِينَ وَيَجْعَل لَّكُمْ جَنَّاتٍ وَيَجْعَل لَّكُمْ أَنْهَارًا

Allah will provide everything for you. Will send the rain. Will bring forth the treasures of the earth. And even increase you in your wealth and your children. Means the size of your family.

These are now non-conventional sources of money and wealth. Few people go after these sources. We all just go after what we know.

But we overlook so many of these sources. If you believe in these things and you practice these things, Allah will create contentment in your heart. You're going to always feel rich.

And you will always feel ready. And Allah promised you, if you feel so, and you like to do it

وَأَنكِحُوا الْأَيَّامَى مِنكُمْ وَالصَّالِحِينَ مِنْ عِبَادِكُمْ وَإِمَائِكُمْ إِن يَكُونُوا فُقَرَاءَ يُغْنِهِمُ اللَّهُ مِن فَضْلِهِ

If you want to get married, but you feel that you're poor, put your trust in Allah. And Allah will make you rich from His bounties.

Questions and Answers

Question: What advice can you give to the single brothers who have the financial problems?

The first thing I would like to point out over here regarding these financial problems is that sometimes it's only in your mind. So many, many people, they overwhelm themselves with loans, with a lot of debts, and they keep calculating everything every month, and they get really paranoid. They say, oh my God, I'm going to stay in this hole until forever.

And they think that they're going to keep going into this basically rat race, and they will never come out of it. Well, again, first of all, get out of that circle, that hole, and start looking from inside, from outside. And one of the first rules of any hole, the first rule of any hole is stop digging.

If you know that you're in this hole, stop digging. Which means, don't get just get out of your ways of spending. That keeps putting you into this problem.

So if you had past debts, don't try to increase these debts. Try as much as possible, figure out a way to get out of these debts inshallah, as soon as possible, as quick as possible. The other thing, you need to sit seriously, to go and calculate all these things, all these now debts and problems that you have, and start to sort your priorities.

Which of these debts need to be finalized first, and how you can do that as quick as possible, make a plan inshallah. Part of this, part of the plan, which I believe, wallahu alam, coming from the Quran, part of the

plans of removing yourself, relieving yourself from most of these debts, is that you get married.

I know it seems to be a paradox, because you say, how come? If I'm going to get married, I'm going to get even extra debts.

Well, it depends on whom you're going to be married to. If you're going to marry someone whose parents will demand thousands and thousands, millions of dollars, that's one thing, but if you're looking for the barakah and for the sitr, that's Allah protect you and protect her, and just bring both your hearts into, inshallah, for this tranquility and peace, it will be very easy inshallah wa ta'ala. Marriage, Allah promised you, that if they were poor, Allah will provide from them, from His bounties.

So Allah will provide for you. Besides, when you get married, we assume, people when they get married, they arrive at a specific level of maturity. At least financial maturity.

Which means now they know that they have responsibility besides their personal spendings, which would help them inshallah wa ta'ala cut down on some of their personal spendings, in order to save. But if you're going to just keep going on, waiting until you become ready to get married, you will never be ready. Because you're going to always stay on that way.

So again, sometimes it's in your mind, get yourself out of that, start making your calculations in the best way inshallah, and see how to reduce all these expenses, and then make marriage as one of your ways of getting out of debt.

Question:

If you have made mistakes in your past, but you have sincerely repented, and are making sure that you are not repeating these mistakes anymore, then is it necessary to inform your potential spouse about these mistakes? Can you hide these mistakes? Will Allah hide these mistakes for you?

As for Allah, I'll leave it for Allah azzawajal. Because Allah, as the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam mentioned on the Day of Judgment, when Allah azzawajal brings the believer to the account, and starts to admit, basically expose the records for them, and if they were really sincere about what they did, and if they really sincerely repented, the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said,

قَدْ سَتَرْتُهَا عَلَيْكَ فِي الدُّنْيَا وَأَنَا أَغْفِرُهَا لَكَ الْيَوْمَ

Sahih al-Bukhari 2441

And I kept, I hid these from the people, means I just kept them between you and me in the dunya, and now I forgive you for these mistakes.

So Allah might indeed hide these mistakes from the people. It's between you and Allah. Besides, we all know, we all have our own mistakes and our own blemishes.

How many mistakes we have done in our life, and we know for sure that Allah is hiding them. And we're always afraid and terrified that people would know about them. That's very natural.

But just keep asking Allah to keep this between you and Him. As now, are you obligated to reveal these mistakes? Well, if you say that you repented, and you nobody knows about these things, or at least in that circle where you are right now, no one knows about these issues. It's only between you and Allah.

You don't have to expose yourself. You don't have to go and tell her, say, listen, by the way, I was just childish and I have done all these things and started counting all these sins. You don't have to do that.

And if they ask about your past, tell them, I really didn't have that glorious past, but I ask Allah to forgive me. That's all I can say. And if they insist on you to say, listen, did you commit adultery? Did you commit fornication? Tell them this is between me and Allah.

Even if I did that, I don't have to tell you. So you don't have to expose yourself regarding these issues. But if the person is not really sincere, not serious about repentance, and you could tell that there are signs of some kind of flip-flopping between these sins and going back again to repentance and so on, in this case, yes, you have the right to question that person.

Question:

How is our Ummah going to have a future in order to serve Allah if the sisters cannot get married if they are pursuing higher education? How will we make tomorrow's leaders?

Ask yourself. Don't ask me. If the sisters are busy doing their education and the guys are waiting for them to finish, they're getting old, sisters are getting old, no one is getting married, eventually they say, you know what, that's it. It's too late for me.

Some sisters, they decide not to marry at all. Some guys decide to marry from overseas because it's going to be a big headache to marry someone who is overqualified for them. So you're going to always have this problem.

And what I'm saying here is that it is okay. You can pursue education as high as you wish. But if you won't like to get married, this is the point.

If you're going to get married, you're going to have to play it by its rules. It means the rules of marriage. And you cannot manipulate these rules.

Allah set rules for marriage. Who is responsible for this? Who is responsible for that? There are certain things we call them rights and obligations. Men, they have rights in the house and they have obligations against them.

Women, they have rights for them and also obligations against them. If you maintain rights and obligations, inshallah, Allah will indeed provide the peace and tranquility He promised you. But if you start now jumping on these rights and obligations, abusing the rights and obligations of the other spouse, that will create this kind of instability in the social network.

And therefore you see many people start fighting again over issues. They consider them their own rights and obligations of the other party.

Question:

If a non-Muslim sister would like to accept Islam and marry a Muslim brother, is it wrong for her to hide this from her parents? She is worried that they would be heartbroken. Please advise.

Well, first of all, the issue of becoming a Muslim is indeed an obligation that every human being should really take the chance to explore this faith sincerely. And this is the message of Islam.

It's a universal message. All people are obligated to make an effort to learn about Islam. And may Allah open their hearts and open their minds for guidance.

Now, the issue of becoming a Muslim, that's one thing. And the issue of getting married to that person is another thing. And the issue of the parents right now comes in the middle.

So becoming a Muslim by itself, I'm sure that it's not going to be an easy decision you make for your parents. So you have to educate them about this issue. If they don't accept that, which is natural, of course, for parents specifically, if they are adherent to their faith and they don't want to have their kids go out of the fold of their religion, in this case, if they decide, of course, or if they don't accept your acceptance to Islam, that's one of the tests and the trials Allah has subjected you to.

To see the sincerity of your Iman if you're afraid. So, may Allah help you. May Allah confirm your heart on Iman and Islam.

Now, the issue of marriage might be the second chance, which is probably, inshallah, will be helpful to you to confirm your deen. It doesn't mean that you cut your ties with your parents. We don't say that.

We are obligated to be kind to our parents, regardless of their faith. Allah commands us about being so kind to our parents.

وَصَاحِبْهُمَا فِي الدُّنْيَا مَعْرُوفًا

And even if they try to persuade you to commit shirk, which means to associate partners with Allah

فَلَا تُطِعْهُمَا

Don't obey them in that.

وَصَاحِبْهُمَا فِي الدُّنْيَا مَعْرُوفًا

And maintain a good and kind companionship with them. So, regardless of their religion, you need to maintain a good companionship with them. But still, you need also to accept this as a test coming from Allah for you.

Question:

If a prospective spouse's family is low-class or poor? Now, in the perception of course, of the questioner. Is that a valid excuse for the parents to reject?

Well, the issue of class and social status and so on is one of these categories of comparability in Islamic law. Remember what I said earlier.

That there are two qualities the ulema, they all agree on. There is unanimous agreement on these two qualities. That's faith and good manners.

Anything else comes next. And the ulema, they argue about it. Not all the ulema, all Muslim scholars agree on these other qualities for comparability.

One of these issues is the issue of class and the issue of social status. Some of the ulema, they say those of the same class should marry from each other. A man from an upper class can marry from a lower class.

But the upper is a little bit difficult. Why? Because now the issue of social status right now, it's subject to the patriarchal system to the family of the man. Or the woman, basically.

If she marries someone from a lower class, she brings shame to her social network and family and so on. All these, as I said, just issues discussed in books of not necessarily agreed upon by all Muslim scholars. Is it a valid reason for her family to reject the person? It depends on the circumstances.

I cannot really judge this because according to the questioner it says low class or poor. I don't know what's the meaning of that and how rich or high class the questioner is. So it depends on the circumstances.

But sometimes it is illegitimate if there is a great deal of I would say difference, great difference between both contracting parties. What if she wants to marry him anyway? She has the full right to say yes. And she has the full right to try to enforce that if she wants.

But I do not recommend that. Because eventually you're going to need someday, you're going to need the support of your family. Because this is not about you and him, it's about all the social network in the society.

Two families representing two different public cultures, two different communities will establish a stronger bigger community as well. If you are looking for a wife, what do you do? Still the question goes on. The question goes, do you look for somebody you love and beautiful? For the first part, if you're looking for a wife, what do you do? First of all, before you start looking for a wife, make sure that you're ready for that.

And if you're still too young for this, it's too early to ask the question. But if you're of that age, it means you're ready to go and start looking for a spouse, bismillah, inshallah, may Allah make it easy for you. In this society, in the traditional, I would say, traditional and conventional ways of doing it goes usually through the women's social network, which means the mother, the sister, relatives, they go and they look and they ask.

If they have a larger social network, it makes it easier for them. If not, like in our society over here, because we don't know probably a lot of people from the same family maybe in that area, so they're going to have to go through what is available in their communities. And usually the masajid, a good chance for people to go and look for.

Islamic conferences, gathering like these, I'm sure that many brothers and sisters, they have in their mind the idea of maybe, who never knows, and I know a lot of older ladies, they approach these young girls during these occasions. So they come and they just bluntly sometimes say, are you married?

You know, I have a nice son, he's an MD, he's a doctor, he's this, he's that. So they try to propose right away on the spot.

If they can do it, that's a good way. But if not, I still say that we lack really enough halal venues for matrimonial services, and I encourage that every single community to work hard in helping their youth. I don't want our kids to be outsourced to other communities.

What is going on in reality right now, most of actually the youth is going through the process of outsourcing right now. So they go and they marry from another community. You hear in New York, for example, you have hundreds of young men and young women, but you see most of these young men and women, they go and they marry from outside New York.

They go to Chicago, for example, or Atlanta. They go to California, and so on. Why? For some reason, subhanallah, it's greater on the other side.

And you see that people from California, they also come to New York, and they want to marry from here. So why? Because it seems that the young men and women over here, being so exposed to the culture of their own fellow brothers and sisters here, they don't really feel comfortable engaging from their own community, and I don't recommend that. I would say, try to find this social satisfaction within your community.

And one thing I would like to warn the brothers and the families from, in the process of getting married, you see many young men, what they do, because of the high demands and expectations of Muslim families, they just quit the idea of marrying from a Muslim family, and they go and they marry a non- Muslim woman. Which is halal, if she was a Christian or a Jew, it is okay. There's no problem with that, Islamically.

But remember, for every brother who marries a Christian or a Jew, or even for every brother, every man, who marries from outside his community, and for every brother who is married from outside the country, there is one sister left behind here. Why is that? Because men have the liberty, probably, to marry second, third, fourth. Women, they only marry Muslim.

So therefore, you need to also consider this also on the long run. And what you should be looking for, I mean, you should attend the Love Notes or Fiqh of Love. We gave a whole seminar on this issue.

But the first, the most important, the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said;

تُنكَحُ الْمَرْأَةُ لِأَرْبَعٍ: لِمَالِهَا وَلِحَسَبِهَا وَجَمَالِهَا وَلِدِينِهَا، فَاظْفَرْ بِذَاتِ الدِّينِ تَرِبَتْ يَدَاكَ

Sahih al-Bukhari 5090

A woman is married for four qualities.

Document

The Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) said she should be married for her beauty, for her lineage, for her wealth, or for her deen. And then he said, means look for the one who is religious, and you'll be blessed.

If you can find all these qualities in one person, Alhamdulillah Rabbil Alameen. If not, then you're going to have to do some kind of compromise. But if you're going to compromise any quality, don't you ever compromise the issue of deen and akhlaq.

Religion and mannerism. And there's a difference between deen and akhlaq. Being religious does not guarantee that the person, man or woman, will be mashAllah very pious and well mannered.

Because in some cultures, being religious means being more rigid. The more rigid you are, the more religious you are. That's how they perceive that.

And that's wrong. Piety and righteousness is all in what Allah commands and avoiding the prohibitions in the Quran, the Sunnah of the Prophet. So it's not about being rigid.

Prevent yourself from so many of the halal things. No. Practice the halal.

Do the commands and avoid the haram, and you'll be the most righteous person. How can a man or a woman learn about the personality of the other party? If he does not ever talk to her, asking family and friends about a person's character, can only hmm something is missing can only anyway, how will I know if she is the right person for me? Well, alhamdulillah, first of all, you would need to introduce yourself to the family, and the family accepts the initial proposal. Then you will have this betrothal time.

The betrothal period, you can come together under the supervision of a mahram. You can talk as much as you want, as long as you want. You can explore areas of family life and future as much as you want.

So basically, you have the time for you to discuss so many issues directly. You see him, you see her, and you sit together, again supervised, discussing so many things. Does the mahram have to sit in the middle between you and stick in his nose between your faces, should be no sightseeing during that conversation? The answer is no.

They can be sitting there in that same room, for example, at least, they can observe the session from a distance, so you can talk freely if you want. As long as there is no supervision right now from parent and supervision, then it's okay to do so. After that, of course, you can make your decisions.

If anyone marries a girl from a different culture, what kind of problem will it create in the future? Allah knows, it depends on their approach of their, of course, marriages. Because I know when you have two cultures coming together in a marriage, it will be very hard and difficult sometimes to communicate. It will be a lot of, basically, specifically between the two families.

It means her parents and his, they might misunderstand, miscommunicate a lot of things, and even sometimes the slightest thing can create a problem. Even the spices in the food can make a big problem.

This is too spicy, this is too blunt.

How do you cook the food? Sometimes it creates problems of that kind. So, I would say it depends on the two parties and their cultures, where it's exactly coming from. There might be some kind of issues, and there might be, Alhamdulillah, a lot of harmonies among these communities.

The thing is, it depends on how much integrated these cultures in the actual community itself. So, in New York here, for instance, I don't know how much you guys are integrated into the different cultures, which means do you have, let's say, the Arab culture, the African culture, the local culture, the overseas culture, all together integrated in one melting pot, or do you have this unofficial cultural segregation in the community? It depends. I have visited some communities, specifically smaller communities, and all of them, to survive, they had to go and break all these cultural barriers.

So, there isn't much difference, and it's easier for them to have interracial marriages. But in larger cities, where you have this unofficial cultural segregation, it becomes harder and harder for them to marry from outside their culture. What is the proper halal way for a woman to approach a man for marriage? First of all, if she's interested in a person, I would suggest to go around some of her closest friends that she can trust, who can have an access, let's say, to information about this person, if he's available or not.

And what if he was married already? What if he was engaged? You don't want to go and, of course, tackle onto the wrong infringing on the wrong domain, basically. So, therefore, you have to make sure that the person is free. In this case, after you know that he is, let's say, free, you can send, let's say, a subtle proposal to, again, a third party, and if the person shows interest, you can pursue that, if you will.

And, of course, by asking him to go and propose directly to the wali. If he's not interested, it's over. At least that would save you all the troubles, of course, and the pain.

At least minimize that pain. Can she go directly to propose to someone? Can a woman come and directly propose to her brother, says, brother, you know what? MashaAllah, I see that you're such a righteous person, a good man, and I would like to propose to you. Have you guys ever received something like this before? Or are you just dreaming about it? No.

Because Ibn Sahih al-Bukhari, Imam Bukhari, rahimahullah wa ta'ala, he established a whole chapter on this issue. It is permissible for a woman to propose directly to a righteous man. She's allowed to do that.

And he brought Hadith Anas, radiyallahu ta'ala, mentioning a woman who came to the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, proposing to him. A woman came proposing to the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. So the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, he looked at her, and then felt shy, kind of felt shy, so he nodded his head down, which means, what does that mean? It means no.

He didn't want to continue looking because he has no interest, so he says no. Which means it's basically no. The woman, she kind of felt frustrated, or maybe didn't know what to do, so she just sat down.

A man was sitting next to the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, says, ya Rasoolallah, illam lakum bika hajaj zawujniha. Means if you have no interest in her, can I marry her? Now the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, turned to her, because it's her issue. The woman, she didn't mind it.

So he said, okay, do you have anything to offer her? Like a dowry, mahr, basically a wedding gift. He says, I don't have anything right now. He said, go and check for anything.

So he went and he looked, he couldn't find anything, came back again, said, ya Rasoolallah, couldn't find anything. So the Prophet said, go ahead, go and look for anything, even if it was just an iron ring, which means something insignificant in material value. Just go offer anything.

The guy was so poor that he went back again, looked for everything, didn't find anything. He said, ya Rasoolallah, ila amriku illa had. I have nothing except for this.

And he put his loincloth that wraps his waist with. And the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, said, what is she going to do with this? If she takes it, you're going to be walking around naked. So the man himself also felt kind of frustrated, he didn't have anything, so he sat down, kind of sad as well.

Then the Prophet said, okay, fine. Do you have anything of the Quran with you? Means, do you memorize anything of the Quran? He said, I know surat kadah, surat kadah, surat kadah. I know these few surahs.

زَوِّجْتُكَهَا بِمَا مَعَكَ مِنَ الْقُرْآن

(Sahih al-Bukhari 5149)

Means, you marry her with the Quran that you have. Means, that was her mahr. Means, to teach her the Quran that you have. And allahu a'la, but probably they lived happily ever after. Allahu a'la.

The point is, according to this hadith, Imam Bukhari said, it is permissible for a woman to directly propose to a man. It's okay to do that. Of course, that depends on the culture as well.

In our sharia, one of the five maxims governing Islamic law, is a very important maxim that governs Islamic law, called al-adha muhakkama, which means custom rules. When there is no specific law from the Quran or the sunnah to explain, interpret something, then we go back, we shelter back, we find a shelter in the adha, which means the custom. If the custom does not contradict the laws of sharia, it should be accepted in some of the areas regarding the enactment of law.

And in this case, if here the custom, let's say, it's okay for a woman to go straight forward to propose to a man, that's fine. But in some other cultures, if a woman does that, it's kind of offensive to them. So, don't even try it.

It depends. And I know a friend of mine, I mentioned that story last night actually, or was it the night before that? A friend of mine, who was a marshal, he's a very nice person, and he was trying to take his classes from the board at the university, he was studying sharia even, and all of a sudden he hears a female voice from the side, saying, assalamu alaikum. And he goes, wa alaikum assalam.

Then she goes, can I talk to you for a moment? And then he just looked, he found a sister with a niqab, and she was looking at him, and he was looking around, there was nobody else but him. So he goes, me? She says, yeah, you. Can I talk to you? He says, yeah, how can I help you? She said, well, listen brother, I don't want you to be offended, but I have been, mashallah, watching you for this past semester.

And I heard so many things about you, you seem to be a very nice and gentle person, I'd like a man who's, mashallah, very generous, very religious, blah blah blah blah. And then she goes, I would like to propose to follow the sunnah and propose to you. The guy ran away.

He felt so shy, he didn't know what to do. He was so shy, I know him, the man is, mashallah, he's so sweet. He's so sweet, he's so shy.

And then he just didn't know what to do, so he just ran away. But the lady, she kept going after him, later, of course. Not at that session, she didn't go after him right away, but she went and she sent other messages to him, and she sent other people to talk on her behalf, and so on.

Eventually, the man kept saying, no, no, no. I don't want to go through the details of his life and why and so on, but eventually he didn't marry her. So not all love stories end with the same clause, happily ever after.

And not all love, as you see, is in exchange, reciprocal, from both sides. It might be from one side and there's nothing from the other side. So it might be a test for some people.

That's it? Okay. Khair, inshallah wa ta'ala.

Closing

وَاللَّهُ تَعَالَى أَعْلَمُ
جَزَاكُمُ اللَّهُ خَيْرًا سُبْحَانَكَ اللَّهُمَّ وَبِحَمْدِكَ. أَسْتَغْفِرُكَ وَأَتُوبُ إِلَيْكَ